Anime of Tomorrow
Tag Archives: Kanji
Final impression – play the game first (7/10)
Fall 2011 to winter 2012 (25 episodes)
Yuu Narukami is a city boy, who for various circumstances at home, ends up moving out to the countryside to live with his uncle and little cousin. But being a naturally suave and likeable guy, he’s quickly able to shake off the aura of being a transfer student and makes some friends. But when the tiny town of Inaba he finds himself in is rocked by a series of bizarre murders, he gets caught up in a creepy cold case where the victims are seen on a mysterious TV program called the Midnight Channel that airs on foggy nights when you have your TV turned off. In the face of such unbelievable circumstances, Yuu and his friends become the only ones capable of rescuing the victims by diving into the television and fighting the bloodthirsty monsters that live there using a manifestation of their psyches called Persona.
Writing an objective review on P4 was difficult for me since I’ve played the game it’s based on. This isn’t the same as reading the manga that serves as the source material for an anime since both of those media are non-interactive. Video games on the other hand are and being put in the position of having no influence on the characters’ decisions or the pace of the story was a little unsettling. I wonder if many other people feel this way about adaptations of video games that aren’t a loose reinterpretation of a concept, but instead a faithful retelling of the same story.
That being said, P4: The Animation recreates the events of the game as closely as is possible, with a few changes made that were probably necessary for the transition to TV. This includes obvious things like completing a side character’s story in a single episode rather than the game’s slower progression that might be spaced out over the course of the entire play time (or even not completed at all if the player neglects that particular social link). But one thing that always disappointed me about P4: The Animation was the fight scenes. The game is something of a visual novel built around the framework of a really solid RPG. That setup should have been a natural cue that the anime ought to be an action / drama. And while the drama does well, the action is dry and has an air of inevitability to it that never feels the slightest bit suspenseful.
All in all, it makes me sad because, because I loved the game and my hopes were high that the anime would live up to that same level of quality. If nothing else, the soundtrack for the P4 anime is even more amazing than the game and includes all of the original music in addition to new and expanded tracks with terrifically-written English lyrics that really gets me fired up. In the end, Persona 4: The Animation is a supplemental anime for fans of the game, but still a very solid series.
Impression – straightforward, yet philosophical
Autumn 2011 to winter 2012 (more info)
As good as the Persona 4 video game was, I wish its anime series would deviate more from the default script or fill in some more fine details that have thus far flown under the radar. Arguably, fans of the video game are going to be the primary fanbase of the anime, but if there are no surprises for us we’re not likely to give very good opinions to more casual viewers who may only have a passing interest. So the plot of Persona 4 is stuck in a weird catch-22 where it needs enough new material to keep the old fans interested but it also needs to stay true to the original story. In some ways, it’s suffering from some of the same problems as Fate/Zero. But it’s more than worth it to watch Persona 4 just for the killer music and sharp art style that is an intrinsic quality of Atlus. One of the things the anime does get right that is a perfect mirror of the video game is the pacing of events to match real dates and create a tangible passage of time. And while the story may have felt more natural in video game format, it’s still totally awesome. Its best points are a cast of varied, loveable characters, a good sense for spinning elaborate mysteries and an overarching theme of emphasizing the importance of the bonds we share with our friends. When you think about it like that, there’s not much else to be desired.